Have you ever wanted to revisit your first love? A better question: who hasn’t? Blue Jay explores this desire so precisely that it may as well be a time travel movie. It stars Mark Duplass and Sarah Paulson as Jim and Amanda, high school sweethearts who bump into each other a couple decades down the line in the town where they grew up. Neither lives there any more, but they have both returned home at key moments. Jim’s mother has died; Amanda’s sister is giving birth. When they lock eyes at the grocery store, an old flame is rekindled, and it still burns brightly.
